Atkins Diet Misconceptions: High Protein or High Fat Diet?
This is the second in Atkins Diet misconceptions or myths series, and in this video I deal with the thought this is a high protein diet. Just check out google for “Atkins Diet” and “high protein,” and you’ll see how prevalent this misconception is.
USDA Food Pyramid Standard for Protein:
10-35% of Total Calories
http://health.msn.com/weight-loss/articlepage.aspx?cp-documentid=100186268
http://www.health.gov/DietaryGuidelines/dga2005/document/html/chapter5.htm
With 35% being the standard for high protein, what does Dr. Atkins recommend?
“The macro-nutrient breakout in the Induction phase is 60 percent fat, 30 percent protein and 10 percent carbohydrate. It should be more appropriately be called a high fat regimen. As you progress through the phases, your percentage of fat naturally diminishes as your percentage of carbohydrates increases.” Even in DANDR, he cautions against going high protein on page 43,
“No, because when you cut out fat, what is left is protein and carbohydrate, both of which can produce a blood-sugar response. Fat is the only substance that won’t have an impact on your blood sugar. It also provides essential fatty acids you can’t get from protein or carbohydrates. Contrary to much of what you may have heard, fat can be good for you! (43)”
Dangers of low fat, low carb, high protein diet:
Sources:
* http://www.nationmaster.com/encyclopedia/Rabbit-starvation
* http://www.medbio.info/Horn/PDF%20files/rabbit%20starvation.pdf
Rabbit starvation is the form of acute malnutrition caused by excess consumption of any lean meat (e.g. rabbit) coupled with a lack of other sources of nutrients usually in combination with other stressors, such as severe cold or dry environment. Symptoms include diarrhea, headache, lassitude, a vague discomfort and hunger that can only be satisfied by consumption of fat or carbohydrates.
How much protein is advisable:
*** .8 – 1.2g per kg of body weight – normal adults, or roughly 72g to 109g per day for 200 pound adult
*** Up to 1.6g per kg – for extremely active or weight lifting adults, or 145g for 200 pound adult (29%)
Source:
** http://sportsmedicine.about.com/od/sportsnutrition/a/Protein.htm
** Protein requirements for endurance athletes. Nutrition , Volume 20 , Issue 7 – 8 , Pages 662 – 668. M . Tarnopolsky
Duration : 0:8:43
Tagged with: Atkins • Bowulf • Carb • Diet • Fat • high • Low • Misconceptions • protein
Filed under: low-fat diet plan
Like this post? Subscribe to my RSS feed and get loads more!
@3d86 “Could you …
@3d86 “Could you please explain to me why a long term high fat diet wouldn’t result in Ketosis”
That’s the point of a ketogenic diet to put the body in ketosis — a natural state for the body. You seem to be confusing ketosis and ketoacidosis — two completely different conditions. One occurs with highly insulin resistant people and one with insulin senstive people, and the number of ketones in one blood is a magnitude of ten different. Check out my video here regarding the difference.
Everyone has their …
Everyone has their opinion, that is the beauty of free speech. I do have a question however. Could you please explain to me why a long term high fat diet wouldn’t result in Ketosis? I’m sure there is a valid explanation I just thought that as in Diabetics a high level of beta oxidation would result in excess Acetyl CoA which when not used to drive citric acid cycle leads to elevated blood Ketone concentration
@bowulf
Crap!! …
@bowulf
Crap!! Thats a good point bowulf…I was being an idiot promoting meat to vegetarians and other occasional meat eaters as being healthy I never realised that if demand for it went up it would mean costs of meat would go up (since governments are so busy just subsidising carbs. Ok no more promoting meat, I will happily stand in the front row promoting vegetarian and vegan diets to everyone and eating my steaks and fried chicken in my private time
@Bootelicious4u Wow …
@Bootelicious4u Wow such insight for someone with no credentials or insight to provide others. Good luck on your plant based diet, but I would prefer a diet where I can all the energy I need to fuel my marathon and resistance training. As for safety, there is as much danger or lack thereof in a plant-based approach as in the Atkins Diet.
I think this dude …
I think this dude doesn’t know what he is talking about. I am on a plant protein diet..using smoothies. It works, you lose weight and build muscle while toning.. So maybe he should go back to school and get a real education. I am on the plant protein diet and Ive lost weight.. a safe weight lose and no side of effects…I laugh at the people on youtube all saying they know everything..UMMM NOT
Wow there are so …
Wow there are so many errors in that short sentence, I can only conclude your blood glucose levels are crashing. Take your idiocy elsewhere.
II spoke to Dr. …
II spoke to Dr. Atkins (On the phone ,once) and even that Moron said it was only intended to be a short term diet.
Great, then we …
Great, then we agree that you have utter clue on what you are talking about and should hang out elsewhere where your contributions might actually be relevant. I’ll leave it up to your own discretion where that is because it certainly is not here.
Regardless of your …
Regardless of your mangled English and delayed thought process due to a lack of vital energies, you are entirely correct. I am glad we agree. It is misguided to speak with authority on things well outside of our grasp and education level.
Really because the …
Really because the only misguided ignorant person is one who comments on things they have no clue regarding.
Atkins Diet …
Atkins Diet Misconception Number 1:
Some people on the Atkins diet are not brainwashed fools.
Fact:
They are all misguided fad dieters with no nutritional or biological background, who are easily convinced by pseudo science.
I too am usually in …
I too am usually in the 150ish range daily, and never have had a problem of any sort. It’s a blessing when you find out what works for you.
Max is a great …
Max is a great guest. I eat a very high protien diet up to 200 grams a day with no ill effects. Approx 50% of my diet comes from fat as well. Carbs are tolerated only during and after working out. Only after loosing the weight did I add in my workout carbohydrates. Atkins saved my life.
Yes after weeks of …
Yes after weeks of organ shutdown in which the kidneys no longer process fluids, guess what you retain water. Chronic heart problems from an infection. As for “no way eating meat is good for you,” funny after 37 years. countless physicals, blood analysis, and running marathons, my body, doctor, and health all seemingly say I am doing pretty well. I have no problems with weight or blood sugar.
BTW – thank for you not eating meat, so it’s cheaper for me.
his weight was 258 …
his weight was 258 pound at the time of death, he has chrornic heat problem, and no way eating meat is good for you
If by heart attack, …
If by heart attack, you mistyped and meant slip and fall on the ice. Then yes you are correct. If not, then you are just perpetuating a myth although with your vegan friends and background I doubt you are interested in truth over your bias.
founder of atkins …
founder of atkins diet dead with heart attack due to eating all that animal fat
If they are eating …
If they are eating according to the plan, there are no unhealthy fats in it. Just frying even deep fat frying the foods in regular cooking oil like peanut or even corn does not increase the transfat content of the food. Frying in some unholy concoction of hydrogenated oils like crisco can, but then again Dr. Atkins was one of the first people speaking out against added transfats.
well yea is true …
well yea is true protein makes u feel more full… but that depends on the person if they can keep a healthy weight or if they want to lose weight…but for example…if u wanna gain muscle and just eat alot of protein but no carbs.. ur actually not letting the body use all the protein ur eating cus the body will use protein for its main energy source if u dont have enough carbs…so unless your happy with how much ur gaining, you wont be able to get much bigger..but again it depends..
i know what trans …
i know what trans are…and they are also in deep fried foods…what im saying is that alot of people will get the wrong message…and start eating things high in fat and not just the good ones..
Wow… There is so …
Wow… There is so much wrong I have no idea where to start. The only place you get trans fat is from partially hydrogenated oils, which are found no where on this diet. Sat Fats – first the media has it wrong — check out my cholesterol videos, and second check out the fat content of beef. It has as much mono-unsaturated as saturated fats. Check your facts first!
naffyking you are …
naffyking you are SO RIGHT! I have NEVER heard of anyone losing 200 pounds by “watching what they eat”, by “taking the stairs instead of the elevator” or by “just cutting back” or as you say, by a “balanced diet”.
I tried losing …
I tried losing weight for years just trying to limit the bad — i.e. maintain past bad habits (Chinese buffets, pizza, etc.) but lessened, but like any addict, you can’t control the bad forever. It’s beast just waiting to go wild. Put it in a cage and off limits, suddenly your life and remaining at goal is manageable.
eating high protein …
eating high protein diets quenches the bodys desire for food (hunger) and also burning more calories than you eat is a proven method for loosing weight i have helped hundreds of people loose 20,30,40, and even 50 kgs , so by eliminating carbs from the diet, does infact work, i have how ever never helped or herd of someone loosing weight on a “balanced diet”
Sorry for the typo. …
Sorry for the typo. The lecture is titled “Big Fat Lies”.
I have to state, you chose your words well. The ideas you wrote on your encounters are well placed. This is an incredible blog!
Anyone have any links to cheap supplies diabetic supplies